[Column] Exercise more beneficial than dieting < Opinion < Article


For well being and longevity, train is extra helpful than weight reduction. Even when you improve the quantity of train, you could fail to drop some pounds. Nonetheless, train is more practical to cut back mortality than occurring a food regimen. When overweight or obese individuals begin exercising, their untimely mortality charges can go down by greater than 30 p.c. The advantages of train are evident even and not using a vital change in physique weight. Nonetheless, the impact of occurring a food regimen just isn’t clear. In some circumstances, the mortality fee will increase, and even when the mortality fee decreases, the extent was not massive in comparison with the impact of train.

Why is that this so? The reply is within the yo-yo impact, described in a 2021 evaluate paper by Glenn Gaesser, professor of train physiology at Arizona State College. Even when you drop some pounds arduous, the vicious cycle of gaining weight once more continues, making it simple to endure from well being issues because of weight-reduction plan. Anybody who has ever been on a food regimen is aware of how troublesome it’s to take care of weight.

Urge for food is essential for survival. It can’t be compelled to go away. Psychologists Peter Herman and Janet Polivy carried out an attention-grabbing experiment on this within the Nineteen Seventies. Individuals had been requested to drink a high-calorie milkshake after which to style and fee cookies, truffles, and nuts. Because it was after the milkshake, most members ate much less of different meals. Nonetheless, individuals on a food regimen did the other. After ingesting the milkshake, they ate much more cookies, truffles, and nuts on the tasting. The psychology of pondering, “Oh properly, screw it, I already overate so I’ll simply eat extra,” appeared to have labored.

In one other experiment, members got a 300 kcal snack however instructed the meals had 600 kcal, and the opposite manner round, a 600 kcal snack with misinformation of 300 kcal. Afterward, they got sandwiches for a meal. Folks on a food regimen confirmed related habits. After perceiving that the snack had excessive energy, they ate extra sandwiches. However those that thought that they had eaten a low calory snack ate much less. Whatever the precise calorie consumption, members ate excessively with the thought that they’ve already failed in weight-reduction plan. Adults, who’re all the time obsessive about consuming much less, act within the reverse option to youngsters who eat much less as a result of they’re full after snacking. Nonetheless, if you don’t hearken to the physiological alerts of the human physique and consciously press it, the second of overeating will come immediately. Then, the food regimen fails and the stomach fats grows again. Then, your well being deteriorates greater than earlier than.

Chances are you’ll say you already know train is sweet however you lack willpower. When that occurs, consider demise. Based on a 2021 research from the College of Waterloo, Canada, messages concerning the threat of illness and demise because of lack of train had been the best in motivating train. Simply pondering that “when you do not train, you may get sick and die rapidly” is a strong motivator. Let go of the need for a slim physique and begin fascinated by surviving first, healthily.


Jeong Jae-hoon is a meals author and pharmacist. He covers a wide range of topics, together with traits in meals, wellness and medicines. This column was initially printed in Korean in Joongang Ilbo on Jan.19, 2022. – Ed.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here